During all three of my pregnancies, I would drive to Sonic and purchase their perfectly-sized, crunchy ice because I had to have it! Whether you prefer to call them pebble ice, nugget ice, or even the infamous “sonic ice,” there’s something so satisfying about those crunchy little ice pellets. In our quest to satisfy the insatiable craving for nugget ice, we embarked on a rigorous testing journey to uncover the best nugget ice maker. We got our hands on four top-rated makers from Amazon and set up shop in our team office kitchen. Over the course of weeks, we meticulously evaluated their performance, ice quality, user-friendliness, and overall satisfaction. Keep scrolling for the results!
You may remember from our viral beverage station that we incorporated a built-in nugget ice maker, which has been a complete luxury. I personally scoop ice from it about five times a day, but it gets full-range use from our family of five. It’s perfect. It’s hooked up to plumbing, so we never have to refill the water or anything. We love a self-sufficient kitchen appliance! It’s also built-in and quite the investment, so for this test we wanted to focus on strictly countertop ice makers. Without spoiling the results, I’ll say that there’s an ice maker out there for every personal preference and budget, and I would actually recommend all four of these for different reasons. Okay, let’s go!
KBice 2.0 Self Dispensing Nugget Ice Maker | Joy Pebble Portable Ice Maker | Kndko Nugget Ice Maker | Opal Nugget Ice Maker with Side Tank
We have had this GE Opal countertop appliance for about a year and a half, actually. We bought it for the team office back in the day so our team could have icy cold beverages at their fingertips. This is “The Ice Maker” that everyone is getting these days. It’s supposedly the best it gets.
I found this pebble ice maker quite attractive and knew we had to test out the dispensing feature to see if it is as convenient as it seems!
Unlike the Opal ice maker, this one has a self-cleaning feature, and it’s less than half the price, so I wanted to see how it compared.
Every test needs a budget contestant, and this ice maker is less than $100, but we, of course, had to see if the value matched the price!
In order of price, low to high.
First impressions? This ice maker is the smallest one of all! It takes up less real estate on your countertop but also holds less ice! The product image makes it look like stainless steel, but it’s actually a gray plastic material. So aesthetically, it’s not ideal. But what about the ice?
The shape of this ice was unexpected! They almost look like styrofoam packing peanuts with hollow insides. The product listing describes them as “bullet-shaped,” which is probably accurate! And you can select either 1-in ice or .8-in ice, although we didn’t notice much of a difference in size.
Surprisingly, we didn’t mind the different shape! It still satisfied the crunchy ice craving, and the texture was great. I think if you’re a small household and don’t have a refrigerator ice dispenser, this is going to make you so happy.
I would say that this ice maker is the budget version of the Opal ice maker. It’s smaller in size and has a really nice stainless steel finish. I also love that it has a flip-top lid for scooping out your ice. According to the product description, this one wins for making the most amount of ice at 3.3 lbs!
As for the actual ice, it’s the perfect size to chew on, but it was a bit more rough around the edges than the others. And somehow, the ice is harder to chew, whereas the others made more soft-crunch ice. Make sense?
Also, this one has a self-clean feature which is so convenient.
In my opinion, this appliance is the prettiest of the bunch. The black/stainless steel combo is lovely and has a really modern, simple shape. It’s also the largest, which is less than ideal if you’re short on counter space. That being said, the dispense on this machine is incredibly satisfying and easy to use.
You won’t ever have to dig out a scooper, and I would trust my kids with this machine because it’s so simple. Oh, and it fits a Stanley cup perfectly without the bottom drip tray!
This isn’t considered a downside, but opposite to the other ice makers, you can’t visually see how much ice has been made. And you can’t see the water level either. Actually, filling it with water is at first odd, but also fun. You poke the funnel into the hole on the frontside and pour the water in. And since you can’t see the fill line from the outside, the machine beeps at you when it’s full.
The ice pebbles are everything you want them to be–top-notch texture and perfectly crunchy. This one also has a self-cleaning feature.
Regarding budget, this particular ice maker stands out as the most expensive, and it also happens to be the one we’ve had and tested for the longest time. I don’t really love that there’s a side tank involved, and it is optional, but I would say it’s pretty necessary unless you’re fine with refilling the water cavity frequently.
Over time, it has required some troubleshooting, and here and there, it makes some random weird sounds, but it does an incredible job of satisfying the pebble ice craving. It also seems to make ice the quickest, and with the side tank, you won’t have to refill very often.
1. KBice – The design, function, and price of this machine make it my favorite! I think the value exceeds the price you pay, and I’ll never get over how satisfying the dispenser is.
2. Opal – While this ice maker performs perfectly well, it’s almost double the price of the KBice machine, and I’m not sure it’s double the value. That being said, it holds significantly more ice, and more water, which means less refilling.
1. Joy – We all had great things to say about this quirky little “bullet-shaped” ice maker. It’s less than $100, and although it’s not ideal for a big family, it would be perfect for college students or newlyweds.
2. Kndko – I would recommend this appliance if you want a great nugget ice maker at a fair price. Although it didn’t win as the most satisfying ice, it’s still pretty dang good. It’s also a bit shocking that it’s smaller in size but also holds the most ice.
If you have a pebble ice maker, be sure to weigh in!
Blender Wars! Testing And Ranking 7 Of The Best Blenders
Putting Kitchen Towels to the Test
We Tested the Top 5 Amazon Pillows–Here’s My Favorite!
Putting Bed Pillows to the Test
Ranking the Top 7 Duvet Inserts on Amazon
The Ultimate Cordless Stick Vacuum Test!
We Tested Rug Pads–Here’s Our Favorite!
Top 16 Best Fall Scents for Your Home
We Tested 30 Hand Soaps to Find the Best of the Best
One component I wish I had been shared was motor noise. (Although maybe they’re all the same so it wasn’t a true variable!) We have the Opal and it is so dang loud when it’s making ice. It’s in our kitchen within range of our living room/TV watching area, and we have to turn the volume up on the TV when the Opal is making ice. :) Just a funny thing I wish I’d researched before buying.
I had a small built in ice maker under my sink on our boat. At first it was a novelty. But the ice cubes were those bullet ones and melted quickly in your drink. We ended up taking it out, selling it, and freeing up all that space by simply putting two ice cube trays in the freezer. I would not buy another. Our freezer at home has an ice cube dispenser and the ice is bigger and harder so it lasts longer in a drink, especially if the pop is not cold to begin with.
We’ve had the GE Opal 2 ice maker for almost 2 years. It requires a lot of cleaning with vinegar & bleach. It’s required a lot of trouble shooting with the “add water” light turning on when full of water & not making ice. We’ve used Costco water (it’s reverse osmosis). It’s so wonderful when it works but a headache to keep it working. We recently bought a Costco ice maker for $89 that makes the bullet ice, lightning fast, to use when our Opal is down. It’s so convenient having reliable ice that I put the Opal away after the add water popped up again. Haven’t missed it. 😉
Can you tell us which Brand/Model you got at Costco? TIA!
I recently bought a Frigidaire Compact Countertop ice maker. It looks like the Joy machine but it is stainless steel. There is also an Iceman portable machine – it has a handle to make it easier to carry around. They are in the 99-109 price range.
I like the size of the ice bullets, but they do melt fast in the drink. I also have some silicone ice trays that make large cubes, which take a while to melt. Check out Amazon to see the variety of sizes and shapes. A lot of the trays have lids to make them stackable. There was a rose shaped option as well as balls, hexies, and other shapes.
The machine is working great – I’ll start it working about 10-15 minutes before I want to have ice. BTW, some of these machines mention that you use tap water, not distilled water.
I really love flakey ice. I worked at a restaurant with it once and I never have really seen it again. So good.
The one thing I had hoped to have reviewed in this is the meltability of the ice. Some of these ice makers the ice seems sooooo thin and melts so fast. Any comment on these four? Did the ice melt super quick like maybe they don’t freeze it all the way through?
I always dump mine into a Ziploc bag and freeze it before using, keeping a supply of ice.
I wonder why you don’t simply freeze ice cubes in your freezer and free up counter space? 🤔
We’ve have the built-in Scotsman nugget ice maker for 9 years now. It is expensive and we love it so much it is worth it! We miss our ice when we go on vacation. We recently moved and it’s the first appliance we bought!
I appreciate the details involved in this comparison. Wish I had read it two week ago as I just bought an Opal, but dang if it isn’t the most perfect crunchy ice. 😉
I love when you do these kind of posts! It’s so interesting and I trust your opinion on them! Thanks!
Our wood grain Shaker cabinet fronts were designed for busy, high-traffic homes like ours. Clad with durable textured thermofoils, this line is compatible with Sektion, Akurum, Godmorgon, and Besta cabinets from IKEA. It's the perfect, practical way to add the warmth of wood to all the rooms of your home.
We have teamed up with Loloi to create a line of rugs that are as affordable as they are beautiful. This collection houses a great mix of traditional and modern rugs, in cottage-y colorways, as well as vintage-inspired beauties that you’ll want to roll out in every room.
We partnered with Stuga on a line of hardwood floors — The Ingrid is really livable, and the color is very neutral. It doesn’t lean warm or cool, it’s that just right in-between. We have really loved putting it everywhere in our house. It’s the best jumping-off point for design, no matter your interior style. In addition to being beautiful, Ingrid is really durable — we have three kids, and we always have a home construction project going on. Ingrid stands up to it all.
Looking for our favorite things? A place to shop our home room by room, or just catch up on what Julia's wearing / loving right now? Browse the CLJ shop.
Befores, afters, mood boards, plans, failures, wins. We’ve done a lot of projects, and they’re all here.
We have a long-standing relationship with DIY, and love rolling our sleeves up and making it happen.
Even when you don’t want to rip down a wall, you can make that space in your home better. Right now.
We recently painted our study a dark, moody green color. This is after we first painted it a muddy green, then repainted it a blue-gray. I guess what they say is true; third time’s a charm! The journey was worth it, though, because I’m so in love with this glossy green in contrast with the […]
We've been doing this since 2009 and we've posted a whopping 24145+ blog posts and counting. You might need a little help searching, huh?
Another way for us to stay in touch! Joining our weekly newsletter gives you access to exclusive content, never-before-seen photos, your questions answered, and our favorite DIYs. Sign up below!
Welcome to our online community where we've posted home, DIY, style, renovations, and family since '09. Renovating our #cljmoderncottage in Idaho and headed for new adventures in Raleigh, NC. #cljfam #cljtransformations
Make yourself right at home
What do you think?