Our Halloween Party, Costumes and Spread

Our party Saturday evening was so fun. We had over 100 people show up but fate was on our side and it was a gorgeous night, so the squished quarters were immediately remedied by opening the back door and people chatting out there, too. Next year I’ll have to remember to string some lights in the back so it feels a little more festive.


We don’t always do themed costumes as a family, but this year we were all characters from Peter Pan. Even Charly joined in the fun and let me put a bonnet on her for a few minutes to be Nana. She was the perfect Nana, too!


A simple blue ribbon (and some elastic for good measure) attached to half of a small tissue paper pom pom made her costume world’s easiest. She’s such a good sport.

The last few years we’ve done a variety of dips. Last year I went the extra mile and carved out pumpkins to house the dips. But this year we did something different for the food. We decided on a caramel apple bar and soup shots.


For the caramel apple bar, we sliced 3 different kinds of apples (we soaked them in water and lemon juice so they wouldn’t turn brown) and melted caramel staying warm in a crock with a slew of toppings. Sprinkles, Heath toffee bits, chopped almonds, crushed Oreos, mini m&ms, chopped Snickers, Reese’s pieces, and crushed Butterfingers. We also decided to add pretzel rods and melted white chocolate to the spread since they paired perfectly with our selected toppings but added a nice, salty dimension to things. It was such a hit! And you could easily make it as healthy or decadent as you’d like.


For something savory, Chris made butternut squash soup and tomato basil soup. To keep it no fuss, we served it in 4 oz “shots” (read: no spoon required). We sliced up some bread for dipping, as well.

There were definitely some hiccups at the party; 2 pictures fell off the wall and broke (!!) right before the first guest arrived–spooky; we forgot to have people vote in the costume contest and there was a good 30 minutes where my camera would not work at all so I didn’t get photos of some of our guests in their costumes–but even with  those things, it was our best party yet. The food and friends were just what we hoped for. Anyone else hit up, or throw a halloween party this weekend? Would love to hear about it!


  • Reply October 27, 2014


    Would you mind sharing the soup recipes? I’ve been on a real soup kick lately, and I love soups with sweet potato, squash, tomato, etc. Thanks!

    • Reply October 28, 2014


      I will definitely put it on Chris’s radar.

  • Reply October 27, 2014


    Just have to say that I love everything about this party! Your costumes are ADORABLE, the photo backdrop wall is creepily awesome, and I love that you kept the menu limited but fantastic. Love the idea of soup shots and the caramel apple bar… delish! You guys are the next big thing! Have a happy Halloween! :)

    • Reply October 28, 2014


      You are so sweet. Happy Halloween to you!

  • Reply October 27, 2014

    Sam @ Away She Went

    I love your group costume! Charly is so cute as Nana. A caramel apple bar is such a great idea for a party and those soup shots look delicious!

    We went to a Halloween party on Saturday and I was Piper from Orange is the New Black. It was probably the most comfortable Halloween costume I’ve ever worn. I tried dressing up our dogs too, but the costumes only lasted long enough for a couple pictures. Our lab was a bumblebee and our heeler was a shark.

  • Reply October 27, 2014

    Meagan Briggs

    Those soups sound amazing (recipes!!!).

    I loved your costumes. Chris in those leggings…epic!

Leave a Reply